Johnny Depp, Amber Heard defamation trial almost has all the makings of a Hollywood hit

0 16

The defamation trial of actor Johnny Depp against his former wife, Amber Heard, has all the makings of a Hollywood hit except for the absence of a single redeeming character. 

The comedian Henny Youngman may have been right that “the secret to a happy marriage remains a secret.” But the Depp trial shows that it is clear how to have a miserable marriage. It includes things like mutually taping each other, throwing objects of varying sizes, and rivaling each other in the competition of conspicuous consumption.

There was gripping and disturbing testimony despite Depp’s tortuously fragmented and rambling accounts. There were the hospital pictures and details of his severed fingertip, which he said was the result of Heard throwing a vodka bottle at him. 

DEPP VS HEARD TRIAL: COURT ADJOURNED UNTIL MONDAY MORNING

Heard’s stony demeanor in court played well for Depp as he described someone who seemed to enjoy torturing him with every weakness.

Conversely, Depp presented himself as a fragile figure tormented by a coniving and greedy spouse.  

Johnny Depp, Amber Heard defamation trial almost has all the makings of a Hollywood hit

FILE – In this Jan. 2, 2016, file photo, Amber Heard, left, and Johnny Depp arrive at the 27th annual Palm Springs International Film Festival Awards Gala in Palm Springs, Calif. 
(AP)

He used his abusive relationship with his mother to not only explain his own inability to be abusive but to paint Heard as a classic case of his marrying his mother. 

Depp may have succeeded in one notable respect. He did not try to hide that fact that he was an utter train wreck of a human being; someone who burned through millions and past relationships. 

JOHNNY DEPP RECOUNTS INFAMOUS DEFECATION INCIDENT IN COURT: ‘I COULD ONLY LAUGH’

Yet, he may have connected on the notion that Heard picked through the rubble to take what she could. Being clueless (even comically clueless) is better than being abusive.

Johnny Depp, Amber Heard defamation trial almost has all the makings of a Hollywood hit

Depp detailed how Heard allegedly flew into fits of violence and abuse to the point that his children did not want to be around her. He alleged that she used nail polish to pretend that he broke her nose while repeatedly leaving him cuts and bruises. 

Heard is heard in one tape admitting that she hit Depp and there were photos offered to support his claims that she was physically abusive.

Depp did likely cause damage to Heard in the end, but now he will be subjected to cross-examination

    Johnny Depp, Amber Heard defamation trial almost has all the makings of a Hollywood hit

    next
    Image 1 of 3

    Johnny Depp confers with his attorney during his libel trial against ex-wife Amber Heard.  (Shawn Thew/Pool Photo via AP)

    Johnny Depp, Amber Heard defamation trial almost has all the makings of a Hollywood hit

    prev

    next
    Image 2 of 3

    Actress Amber Heard, right, watches testimony in the courtroom at the Fairfax County Circuit Courthouse in Fairfax, Va., Thursday, April 14, 2022.   (Shawn Thew/Pool Photo via AP)

    Johnny Depp, Amber Heard defamation trial almost has all the makings of a Hollywood hit

    prev
    Image 3 of 3

    Actress Amber Heard talks to her attorney as she walks in the courtroom at the Fairfax County Circuit Court in Fairfax, Va., Monday April 18, 2022.  (AP Photo/Steve Helber)

. He started poorly in questioning with Heard’s counsel Ben Rottenborn, a name that Depp seemed to like to emphasize on the stand. 

TOP 5 TAKEAWAYS FROM THE JOHNNY DEPP DEFAMATION TRIAL

Depp used a common approach to depositions in drawing out questions and giving hyper technical, nitpicking answers to counsel. 

That does not work well in front of a jury. It makes you look less like a clueless wreck and more like a snarky sophisticate.  You look less like Ingrid Bergman in “Gaslight” and more like Marlene Dietrich in “Witness for the Prosecution.”

The defense continues to hammer Depp on the fact that he was not actually mentioned in the Washington Post column where Heard claimed that she was an abused spouse. It is a curious tactic since that is not necessary for defamation. She was clearly referring to Depp as shown by the tsunami of criticism that followed.

CLICK HERE TO GET THE OPINION NEWSLETTER

What is likely to be more damaging for Depp is the self-inflicted damage to his career. Depp’s drinking and bizarre behavior made him notorious in the media. 

Depp did make a convincing case that his career was effectively ended when Heard first claimed abuse. 

Disney (which owns the “Pirates of the Caribbean” series) had already decided that he would not continue in his most famous role before Heard’s column ever ran. Moreover, she previously accused him of abuse years earlier in seeking a temporary restraining order (TRO). 

Yet, Depp did make a convincing case that his career was effectively ended when Heard first claimed abuse. 

Johnny Depp, Amber Heard defamation trial almost has all the makings of a Hollywood hit

There is no appellate process in the court of public opinion. Moreover, by making the allegation in a court filing, Heard could not be sued for defamation due to immunity rules. She would have to repeat such claims outside of court to lay the foundation for a lawsuit. That did not come until years later with the Washington Post column. By that time, Depp’s career was as sunk as Davy Jones’ locker.

The fact is that it would have been better if this trial were held two years ago when Heard first made the allegations. He is right that, when he was asked on the stand what the allegation cost him and he responded, “nothing less than everything.” 

CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP

In the end, both Depp and Heard seem more intent on mutually assured destruction than actual verdicts in their favor. 

The one thing that is already established is perhaps the best single line from the movie “So I Married an Axe Murderer:” “We both said, ‘I do!’ and we haven’t agreed on a single thing since.” 

CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM JONATHAN TURLEY

Source

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.